So the question becomes: do the COVID-19 vaccines give us low or high levels of neutralizing antibodies? Were in a race with the new variants, Sara Del Valle, a computational epidemiologist at the Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico explained in a March 2021 feature in the scientific journal Nature. Its another step in the decades-long erasure of the fact that our sophisticated and highly effective immune systems work well and dont need any assistance from the biomedical/pharmaceutical industry. As any chicken farmer knows (or any veterinarian like Dr. Vanden Bossche should know), vaccinating against Mareks disease has population health benefits in that it prevents mass death due to the disease, even if the vaccine can allow more virulent strains to evolve. Lets compare Dr. Vanden Bossches letter to what Wakefield wrote back in 2019. Even if they dont prevent all transmissions, it looks like they can drastically cut the transmission chain and also reduce the amount of virus that can be transmitted in these cases. I'm glad I finally know. This material may not be reproduced without permission. As stated, I am not against vaccination. Very interested in spirituality. Coordinated Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunisation's Ebola Vaccine Program and contributed to the implementation of an integrated vaccine work plan in collaboration with Global Health Partners (WHO, Bill \u0026 Melinda Gates Foundation, CDC, UNICEF), regulators (FDA) and vaccine manufacturers to enable timely deployment or stockpiling of Ebola vaccine candidates.Sharing his perspective on mass vaccination in COVID-19.You can support us with a financial contribution through Patreon. Its been accompanied by a video interview posted towhere else?antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.s Childrens Health Defense website. Most times, the virus will not mutate or its mutation will be harmless, but the more people incubate the virus, the bigger the chance of a dangerous mutation emerging by chance. Former Virologist warns HALT ALL Covid-19 Mass Vaccinations In an open letter to the World Health Organization, Geert Vanden Bossche, DMV, PhD warns "all authorities, scientists and experts around the world [and the] entire world population" to put a stop to the mass vaccinations for Covid-19. The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic: Amazon.co.uk: Vanden Bossche MD Phd, Geert: 9781956257809: Books ], Ive frequently discussed how in the age of the pandemic, at least in terms of antivaccine misinformation and pseudoscience, everything old is new again. This is a bad argument. Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche is a world-class certified expert in microbiology and infectious diseases. David H. Gorski, MD, PhD, FACS is a surgical oncologist at the Barbara Ann Karmanos Cancer Institute specializing in breast cancer surgery, where he also serves as the American College of Surgeons Committee on Cancer Liaison Physician as well as an Associate Professor of Surgery and member of the faculty of the Graduate Program in Cancer Biology at Wayne State University. And maybe, at some point, Dr. Bossche validates a new kind of vaccine that works in a completely different way and it eventually allows us to curb the pandemic. Follow. Hola, identifcate. The author delves into the impact of mass vaccination on individual and global health, and explains how powerful organizations, institutions, and industries lacking an . For Dr. Bossche, however, the solution is not long walks on the beach, but an alleged new type of vaccine focused on training the innate immune system. The role of spike protein variability inT cell immunity is likely to be elucidated in experimental studies in the next few months; a priori, the enhanced repertoire of T cell epitopes makes the loss of cytotoxic activity or recognition improbable. Published: 23 Mar 2021. Central to the concept in his article, published via the in-house journal of the American Association of Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), an organization I like to refer to as the John Birch Society of medical societies given its penchant for conspiracy theories and pseudoscience, was that the MMR vaccine, by selecting for more aggressive measles strains, could result in a sixth extinction event. Because, he says, the vaccines are imperfect, they will allow the virus to keep being transmitted from person to person and thus mutate inside of us, until a dangerous new variant emerges. In an open letter to WHO and in a follow-up video interview, Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche, says that by vaccinating everyone with a vaccine that doesn't prevent transmission, we are destroying people's immune systems, and setting the stage for a global health disaster. This is not all that impressive, given that Snopes could only identify two patent applications in Vanden Bossche's name both for "immunologic formulations" and both of these patents, records indicate, had their "applications terminated before publication.". "Cause Unknown": The Epidemic of Sudden Deaths in 2021 & 2022 (Childrens Health Defense), Principles for Dealing with the Changing World Order: Why Nations Succeed and Fail, There are 0 reviews and 0 ratings from the United States, This outstanding body of work that explains the virology of the pandemic the understanding of Vaccines how they work the shortcomings of public health. Dr. Geert Vanden Bossche is a veterinary doctor who also has a Ph.D. in virology. After his career in Academia, Geert joined several vaccine companies (GSK Biologicals, Novartis Vaccines, Solvay Biologicals) to serve various roles in vaccine R&D as well as in late vaccine development. There is a reason why a new flu vaccine is made each year: the influenza virus drifts and shifts and the vaccine needs to be reformulated to be a better match for the specific viruses that are predicted to be common during the next flu season. If the virus manages to do so, it can benefit from the (momentarily) suppressed innate immunity, thereby causing disease in an increasing number of these subjects and ensuring its own propagation. The vaccines are working. This particular coronavirus happens to have a proofreading mechanism that results in a low mutation rate compared to that of a lot of other RNA viruses, such as, for example, the influenza virus. The estimated length is calculated using the number of page turns on a Kindle, using settings to closely represent a physical book. Vanden Bossche has been able to avoid allegations of peddling such a cure at least in the credulous anti-vaccine community because his resume legitimately includes stints at companies or initiatives involved in vaccine development, including The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. As NK cell-based immune defense provides sterilizing immunity and allows for broad spectrum and fast protection, it is reasonable to assume that harnessing our innate immune cells is going to be the only type of human intervention left to halt the dangerous spread of highly infectious Covid-19 variants. A BBC fact check of Vanden Bossche's claim was deemed "false" with multiple vaccine experts saying large scale vaccinations were more likely to weaken the COVID-19 virus, not cause it to mutate to to a morte lethal variant. This is an absurdly counterproductive solution if Vanden Bossche were truly concerned about variants. https://t.co/DPYKE7kxmM, Geert Vanden Bossche (@GVDBossche) March 15, 2021, The science behind the catastrophic consequences of thoughtless human intervention in the Covid-19 pandemic. This is a very confused argument. Samenvatting. I noted then that there was no evidence that mass vaccination with MMR had produced variants of the measles vaccine resistant to the immunity produced by the vaccine, just as I note now that there is as yet no evidence that SARS-CoV-2 variants are resistant to the immunity produced by current COVID-19 vaccines. Thats antibiotic resistance. Waiting for Vanden Bossche's "universal vaccine" is no way to win such a race. Perhaps no more tired a trope exists in the world of faux cures than the "I have found a problem that no other scientist in the world has thought of and only my untested and unproven cure can stop it" gambit. Likely to create more more viral variants in the process.Timecodes:0:00 - Intro7:36 - Lockdowns8:51 - Gaining immunity from exposure \u0026 immunological escape11:17 - COVID vaccine18:30 - COVID antibodies19:55 - NK Cells25:00 - Antigen-specific antibodies outcompete natural antibodies28:51 - Highly-infectious strain31:01 - Vaccine resistance in COVID pandemic31:51 - More on immunological escape32:59 - Geert Vanden Bossches thoughts on COVID vaccinationGeert Vanden Bossche PhD, is an internationally recognised vaccine developer having worked as the head of the Vaccine Development Office at the German Centre for Infection Research. Such claims are generally an offshoot of another favorite antivaccine claim, namely that the diseases being vaccinated against are so innocuous that vaccinating against them is overkill and allowing infection and natural herd immunity to occur is better, a trope that has also been resurrected about COVID-19, a disease thats killed well north of 500K people in just the US in a little over a year. If the body ends up making low levels of these antibodies, i.e. It's important that this book is out there. Ultimately, most vaccines are based on a recombinant spike protein sequence. Amazon has encountered an error. Compre online The Inescapable Immune Escape Pandemic, de Vanden Bossche MD Phd, Geert na Amazon. ", On top of the false notion that imperfect vaccine antibodies will hamper the overall immune system on its own, Vanden Bossche claims that the prolonged lockdowns have left our innate immune system out of practice. He claims that the vaccines will destroy our bodies' ability to use our innate immune system (which produces, among other things, non-specific cells capable of clearing a wide variety of infectious material from the body) to fight off the variants vaccines allegedly could not. As previously explained (see contribution: 'Unravelling the complexity of Covid-19 vaccination shaped by mass vaccination'), this beneficial effect will wane quite Dont you see? So-called leaky vaccines are vaccines that prevent disease, but do not appreciably slow transmission of the pathogen. After all, as Nirenberg and the review article I quoted above note, while it is true that variants of concern demonstrate reduced antibody neutralization, we do not as yet have an absolute correlate regarding how high an antibody level is required to be protective, making the practical meaning of this observation difficult to determine. Immunocompromised individuals with persistent COVID-19 infections, in particular, may play a huge role in the development of variants. Visit Geert at https://www.voiceforscienceandsolidarity.org/ and stay updated on his latest blogs, projects, and videos. If you claim to be not antivaccine but your message is so attractive to a rabid antivaxxer and leader of the antivaccine movement like Del Bigtree that he spends an hour promoting it, you are either deluding yourself about being not antivaccine, or youre a useful idiot for the antivaccine movement, possibly both. His LinkedIn profile lists several impressive positions, including Head of the Vaccine Development Office for the German Centre for Infection Research (for seven months, August 2017-February 2018); Chief Innovation & Scientific Officer for Univac, where he claimed to be an inventor of a new vaccine technology based on natural killer (NK) cells (2014-2016); and the managing director of VARECO, claiming to be a consultant about vaccine development (2012-present). Actually, its not just eerily similar, its almost exactly the same, namely that immunity from vaccines is an evolutionary selective pressure just like the evolutionary selective pressure from antibiotics to which the organism can become resistant.. As a creative thinker, innovator, entrepreneur and visionary, Geert has been invited to speak at multiple international congresses. He also has a Ph.D. in virology and a long-standing career in human vaccinology. David Gorski on March 18, 2021 Tweet For vaccines, resistance equates to strains of the microbe, the virus, or the bacteria that can elude the imperfect immunity created by the vaccine. This brings us to our topic, a misinformation-filled open letter by a scientist named Geert Vanden Bossche that went viral over the weekend. If Dr. Bossche fears the current vaccines so much, what is his solution? I am sometimes accused of attacking the person instead of simply addressing the arguments, but appraising the messenger and the phrasing of the message can be very useful. Read full document here: https://t.co/DPDFlg4U45 pic.twitter.com/TISexYqyTq, Geert Vanden Bossche (@GVDBossche) March 13, 2021. A company claiming to develop such a product is currently registered to an address identified on Yelp as his veterinary practice. One of his topics is labeled, "Why mass vaccinaton amidst a pandemic creates an irrepressible monster." In scenario #2, we vaccinate as many people as we can and as quickly as we can. One answer is, why not? Potentially leaky vaccine but stellar disease reduction. There is a sound scientific rationale to assume that it is possible to prime NK cells in ways for them to recognize and kill Coronaviruses at large (include all their variants) at an early stage of infection. He subsequently worked with the Global alliance for Vaccines and Immunization (GaVI) in Geneva as senior ebola Program Manager and with the German center for Infection Research in Cologne as Head of the Vaccine Development Office. Vaccines can put a stop to that. Edward Nirenberg, a science blogger who addressed Dr. Bossches claims in great detail, points to Mareks disease. Its hard for me not to believe that hes grifting, and this demonization of existing COVID-19 vaccines based on speculative science and no strong data yet is a sales pitch. To all authorities, scientists and experts around the world, to whom this concerns: the entire world population. In fact, I basically said the same thing in 2019 when writing about Andrew Wakefields invocation of the same argument regarding the MMR vaccine and measles variants. At this point, I will also mention that, because Ed Nirenberg produced an excellent rebuttal of Dr. Vanden Bossches mangling of immunology in his letter, Ill stick more to my lane (mostly, anyway), although there will be some overlap. (Truly, those were simpler times.). Vanden Bossche has created a scientific-sounding argument that vaccination will encourage the production of COVID-19 variants that our immune systems will be unprepared to fight. He claims that its because theres so much coronavirus circulating and so many people might produce suboptimal levels of antibody to the virus that, as is the case when antibiotics are used at levels too low to eliminate bacteria and thereby result in strong evolutionary selection for resistant strains of bacteria, a mass vaccination program is doomed to result in resistant variants of coronavirus, particularly when the vaccination program has started out targeted: As if this was not already heavily compromising innate immune defense in this population segment, there comes yet another force into play that will dramatically enhance morbidity and mortality rates in the younger age groups: MASS VACCINATION of the ELDERLY. Without vaccines, the virus is allowed to jump from person to person and make imperfect copies of itself, and this flawed replication process is like a worldwide game of Russian roulette. The author delves into the impact of mass vaccination on individual and global health, and explains how powerful organization As a scientist I do not usually appeal to any platform of this kind to make a stand on vaccine-related topics. It is, as McGill's Jonathan Jarry wrote and as Yale's Omer told us, a classic example of the appeal-to-nature fallacy that invokes the primacy of natural solutions, mechanisms, or substances over those deemed unnatural and human created. Again, the possibility that COVID-19 might be developing resistance to vaccines or immune escape is not a reason to halt the vaccination campaign. If we, human beings, are committed to perpetuating our species, we have no choice lef [sic] but to eradicate these highly infectious viral variants. Nirenberg goes further and notes that the antibody titers induced by vaccines are MUCH higher than those seen after infection, and we see hallmarks of memory responses induced by these vaccines from even a single dose, suggesting that, even though there is a decrease in neutralization by vaccine-induced SARS-CoV-2 antibodies, that might not portend a loss in protection. Interestingly enough, the use of this seemingly leaky vaccine in chickens led to a reduction in the incidence of Mareks disease by 99%. Are vaccines destined for a similar fate? Because of their fast (NK cells) and universally protective effect, Univac vaccines are uniquely suited to prevent pathogenic agents from escaping host immune responses as of an early stage of infection or immune-mediated disease. Follow Us : Tags Coronavirus In the first two letters alone, he uses some variation of the phrase "it is reasonable to assume" at least seven times. He also states that hes worked with GAVI: The Vaccine Alliance and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, although searching the websites, I could find no reference to him other than a report written by him and others to GAVI about progress on an Ebola vaccine. This strategy is based on vaccines that target the adaptive arm of our immune system, the same principle that allowed us to slay smallpox and bring polio and measles down to their knees. For the latest information on COVID-19 and vaccines, Please visit the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. https://www. 1995 - 2023 by Snopes Media Group Inc. Vanden Bossche's argument, however, basically boils down to the idea that current COVID-19 vaccines, in conjunction with other preventive measures, are making the pandemic exponentially worse by breeding infectious variants. The author's predictions are compelling and indicate that Nature will correct this mistake, but at a substantial cost to human lives in highly vaccinated countries. For example, just before the three-minute mark in the video interview of Vanden Bossche by McMillan, Vanden Bossche indicates hes a long-time vaccine developer. Mass Vaccination in a Pandemic - Benefits versus Risks: Interview with Geert Vanden Bossche Vejon Health 46.7K subscribers 1.5M views 1 year ago Highlighting the principle of using a. This piece is an interview conducted by Rob Verkerk, Ph.D., with Geert Vanden Bossche, Ph.D. Geert is now primarily serving as a Biotech/Vaccine consultant while also conducting his own research on Natural Killer cell-based vaccines. "Natural infection kills. Dr. Bossche, however, seems to be a big fan of the innate immune system and he worries that all of these COVID-19 vaccines and public health measures are getting in the way of our innate immune system fighting off the coronavirus. you get antibodies that are no longer able to completely neutralize the virus -we are seeing more and more that mass vaccinations can lead to resistance . National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, Steven P. Novella, MD Founder and Executive Editor, David H. Gorski, MD, PhD Managing Editor, allowing infection and natural herd immunity to occur is better, American Association of Physicians and Surgeons, The Sixth Extinction: Vaccine Immunity and Measles Mutants in a Virgin Soil, excellent rebuttal of Dr. Vanden Bossches mangling of immunology, proofreading mechanism that results in a low mutation rate, Andrew Wakefield wrote about MMR and vaccines, Nirenbergs demolition of Dr. Vanden Bossches nonsense, The Not-So-Hidden Agenda Behind Bossches Concern Over COVID Mass Vaccination, surgical oncologist at the Barbara Ann Karmanos Cancer Institute, American College of Surgeons Committee on Cancer Liaison Physician, Ear Acupuncture for Procedural Pain in Neonates: More Randomized Controlled Nonsense.